Greetings, fellow vibration enthusiasts!
Vibration sensors are essential elements in many engineering and science applications, including structural health monitoring, predictive maintenance, automobile and aerospace design, and seismic activity detection, to name a few. There are several types of vibration sensors available on the market, but two of the most popular are piezoelectric and piezoresistive sensors. In this post, we will compare these two technologies, highlighting their differences and similarities, and discussing their performance metrics.
Piezoelectric Sensors
Piezoelectric sensors rely on the piezoelectric effect, which is the ability of certain materials to generate an electric charge in response to a mechanical stress. When a piezoelectric material experiences a vibration or strain, it generates a voltage that is proportional to the intensity of the vibration. This voltage signal can be measured and processed to obtain useful information about the vibration source.
Piezoelectric sensors present several advantages, including high sensitivity, large bandwidth, and low power consumption. They can detect vibrations in the range of micro to mega Hertz and can tolerate high shock levels without significant damage. However, piezoelectric sensors are temperature-sensitive, and their output can be affected by ambient conditions, such as humidity and pressure.
Piezoresistive Sensors
Piezoresistive sensors, on the other hand, rely on the piezoresistive effect, which is the ability of certain materials to change their electrical resistance in response to a mechanical strain. In a piezoresistive sensor, a strain-sensitive resistor is attached to a mechanical component that experiences a vibration. The resistor changes its resistance proportionally to the vibration, and this change can be measured and processed to extract information about the vibration source.
Piezoresistive sensors also present several advantages, including high sensitivity, wide bandwidth, and insensitivity to temperature and humidity. They are less susceptible to noise than piezoelectric sensors and can be more robust and durable. However, piezoresistive sensors are more complex and expensive to manufacture and require a Wheatstone bridge circuit to read the electrical resistance.
Performance Metrics
To compare the performance of piezoelectric and piezoresistive sensors, we will consider some critical parameters, such as sensitivity, frequency response, temperature range, linearity, and noise.
-
Sensitivity: The sensitivity of a vibration sensor is its ability to detect small changes in vibration amplitude. Piezoelectric sensors are generally more sensitive than piezoresistive sensors, achieving mV/g levels. Piezoresistive sensors can achieve sensitivities in the range of 0.1 mV/g to 2 mV/g, depending on the design.
-
Frequency Response: The frequency response of a vibration sensor is the range of frequencies that it can detect accurately. Both piezoelectric and piezoresistive sensors can detect vibrations in the range of micro to mega Hertz, with piezoelectric sensors having a slightly wider range.
-
Temperature Range: The temperature range of a vibration sensor is the range of temperatures in which it can operate without significant deviations in performance. Piezoelectric sensors are sensitive to temperature variations and have a limited operating range (typically around -40 to 120 °C), while piezoresistive sensors can operate in a wider temperature range (-55 to 125 °C).
-
Linearity: The linearity of a vibration sensor is the ability to provide a proportional output to the amplitude of the vibration. Both piezoelectric and piezoresistive sensors can provide linear outputs with proper calibration.
-
Noise: The noise of a vibration sensor is the unwanted signals present in the output signal. Piezoresistive sensors are generally less noisy than piezoelectric sensors, mainly due to the amplified noise of the charge amplifier required in piezoelectric sensors.
Conclusion
Piezoelectric and piezoresistive sensors are both reliable and accurate technologies for detecting vibrations. Piezoelectric sensors are advantageous for their high sensitivity, large bandwidth, and low power consumption, while piezoresistive sensors are advantageous for their robustness, wide temperature range, and low noise. Choosing between these technologies depends on the specific application requirements and the cost-benefit analysis.
We hope you find this comparison helpful in your quest for vibration excellence! If you have any questions or comments, please let us know in the section below.
References
- Kundu, T. (2016). Ultrasonic nondestructive evaluation: Engineering and biological material characterization. CRC press.
- Chiu, Y. S., & Chen, C. C. (2003). Piezoelectric microdisplacement sensor based on microstereolithography. Journal of micromechanics and microengineering, 13(2), 163.
- Lin, W. Y., Zhang, J. Z., Jia, X. Q., Wang, Y. N., & Fang, D. N. (2015). PID control for a piezoresistive accelerometer considering multiple physical effects. Measurement Science and Technology, 26(3), 035004.
- Junqiang Bai, Xiaodong Zhang, Shengjia Zhang, and Sheng Qiang, “A New Piezoresistive Acceleration Sensor with Low Cross-Axis Sensitivity for Harsh Environments,” International Journal of Mechatronics and Automation, vol. 2, no. 2, pp. 81-88, 2012.